GRM 2010 GRM 2011

WORKSHOP DETAILS

Title: Enhancing the Learning Ecosystem in the GCC: Learning Outside the Classroom (LOtC)

Workshop Directors:

Dr. Asma Siddiki
Alpha1Education LLC
Email: asmasiddiki@alpha1education.com
        
Dr. Rania Ibrahim
Dean of Student Affairs
Effat University

Email: ribrahim@effatuniversity.edu.sa
        

Abstract

Learning is a process of active engagement with experience. It is what people do when they want to make sense of the world. It may involve the development or deepening of skills, knowledge, understanding, awareness, values, ideas and feelings or an increase in the capacity to reflect. Effective learning leads to change, development and the desire to learn more – (Definition used by The Campaign for Learning, 2003; reported in Braund& Reiss 2004).

The main objective of this workshop is to look beyond formal classroom instruction in order to identify means and opportunities for Learning Outside the Classroom (LOtC) as a contributing influence on lifelong learning and the development of a “knowledge society” across the GCC countries. The workshop will be informed by contributions from institutions across all educational levels and all collaborators such as industrial entities, commercial entities, government entities, NPOs, community centres, and youth organisations that could potentially play a role in enhancing the efforts of creating a knowledge society. Challenges and opportunities will be addressed and analysedand recommendations drawn for a holistic, multi-faceted approach to complement the GCC countries’ considerable existing efforts and financial commitments to education and training.

Description and Rationale

With large percentages of national budgets dedicated to education and training, and a committed acknowledgement of education as an economic driving force in the GCC, the recent rhetoric has shifted increasingly and energetically towards the desirable outcome of developing “a knowledge society” that could meet the challenges of the 21st century, globalisation, and technological change (United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), 2003). However, global standardised testing (such as TIMMS and PISA) shows that in those GCC countries that have participated, students have scored well below the average, causing much concern among policymakers and generating extensive analyses of the challenges in improving quality, beyond quantity and access toeducation (Salehi-Isfahaniet al.2011).

In order to tackle the obvious gap between reality and desired aims, policy recommendations have been numerous (see AlMunajjedet al. 2011;Barber et al.2007; Farah 2012; Gonzalez et al. 2008). These are typically consistent in their acknowledgment of the GCC countries’ financial commitments to education, mostly in the “hard infrastructure” of schools, yet varying in their degree of emphasis on the need for further investment in the “soft infrastructure” and areas of focus. These have primarily directed their focus on approaches meant for the education and labour market to address, independently and through collaboration. For example, some have identified the need for improving the calibre and quality of teachers (Hanushek 2005), and their training and professional development, as well as the evaluation of student performance and assessment of school effectiveness (Barber et al.2007), the need for improved and updated teaching curricula and methods, increased use of ICT in the classrooms, increased career counseling, improved compatibility between the output of the educational system and the needs of the employment market, the need for vocational education, more engagement and input from the key stakeholders in the education process, the students (Jamjoom 2013; AlMunajjedet al.2011), with some mention of “extra-curricular educational opportunities such as science clubs and museums” (also AlMunajjedet al. 2011).

Looking beyond the GCC, on the other hand, some of the most competitive countries of the 21st century, such as Finland, are in fact pursuing very different policies to those recommended earlier, emphasizing flexibility and loose standards over standardisation, broad learning combined with creativity (giving ‘equal value to all aspects of an individual’s growth of personality, moral, creativity, knowledge and skills’) over a focus on numeracy and literacy, and intelligent accountability with trust-based professionalism (empowering teachers and heads of school) over consequential accountability of school performance and student assessment (Sahlberg 2007). Standardised testing, the rigid assessments imposed on schools with strictly dictated outcomes and the ensuing impact on limiting the student’s reasoning and intellectual capacity is also criticised by others in developed countries such as the US where student performance and the public education system is also in need of improvement (Wagner 2009; Gatoet al.2010). Yet countries where the system can rely on ‘flexibility and loose standards’ already have other fundamentals in place, such as a highly qualified teaching force selectively and competitively vying forvery respected careers in education. Learning from 'best practices' and aiming for improved teaching, the GCC countries are increasingly establishing initiatives to address the critical issue of teacher training and recruitment.

Simultaneously, many of the related challenges to the provision of a quality education system are being tackled in the GCC countries through reforms to education systems and the labour market. Yet, the infrastructure for developing an ecosystem that values and encourages “learning” (as opposed to “formal instruction”) outside the typical school/classroom model is both weak and little studied in the context of the GCC countries where formal education is heavily relied upon to provide all aspects of ‘education’ (and heavily criticised when it fails to do so).

A look at anecdotal and electronic reporting emphasises that public libraries and museums are lamentably few (Jawhar 2013); a culture of school trips (to industry sites, farms and the natural environment, for example) is both discouraged for fear of waste of school/study time and pursued only by private schools with means; summer camps for those remaining in their respective countries are accessible only to those inurban areas; expeditions outside the country are offered either as sponsored packages to gifted students (e.g., the Mawhibainitiatives for gifted students sponsored by the Ministry of Education in KSA) or limited to students of elite private schools with means, and often limited to male students; commercial ‘edutainment’ centres (such as Kidzania in Dubai) are also few and limited to those in urban hubs. At the tertiary level of education, public universities do not encourage a dialogue with other stakeholders such as industry experts and organisations, and out-of-classroom experiences are limited for private institutions competing for an edgein offerings and the quality of their services (Ibrahim &Sarirete 2011). At the professional level, job training budgets are limited, and often the first to be slashed in crises – with limited opportunities andaffordable providers available for professional development in the first place (with some notableexceptions in each GCC country).

Converging on ‘broad learning’ as an outcome of Learning Outside the Classroom (LOtC), this workshop identifies LOtC as a critical contributing factor to the personal, emotional, social, cognitive and educational development of young people (throughout the K-12 years) (Malone; Council for Learning Outside the Classroom; English Outdoor Council), and to development of Personal Competence, Cognitive Complexity, Knowledge and Academic Skills, Practical Competence, and Altruism and Estheticism of adults enrolled in higher education (Kuh 1993).

Research (mostly conducted outside of the GCC) abounds with studies that emphasise the importanceof LOtC. As far as elementary science is concerned, home-based learning and direct observation were found to be ‘more important sources of knowledge than were schools or books’ (Braund& Reiss 2004). Research on the importance of arts and culture shows that those who ‘engage in the arts or watch others do so are more likely to be civically engaged, socially tolerant, and altruistic,’ deeming an arts educationas ‘essential to preparing .. young people for a global economy fueled by innovation and creativity’ (LeRoux&Bernadska 2012). The International Baccalaureate (IB) in its aims to develop students physically, intellectually, emotionally, and ethically, considers LearningOutside the Classroom (through “experiential learning and …journeys of self-discovery”) a core tool for its Diploma requirements (IB Diploma website). Also, the UK-based Council for Learning Outside the Classroom maintains that “Learning outside the classroom activities… give children and young people the opportunity to work on real-life challenges; handle risk; develop their capacity to think imaginatively and creatively; define and explore complex problems; use and adapt multiple resources both within their community and beyond in order to experiment and devise solutions to these problems” (LOtC website).

This workshop will highlight the critical importance of partnerships in the GCC countries between educational institutions, centres of culture, art, community and science, and commercial enterprises focused on education for enhancing the learning ecosystem for young adults, and similarly, partnerships between tertiary level institutions, industry, research centres of excellence, policymaking bodies and training organisations in order to enhance the learning ecosystem for adults. It will address the social, cultural, and community-based opportunities (whether public, private or, indeed commercial as distinct from private), outside of or complementing the domain of formal education, that enhance ‘learning’ and contribute to the overall objectives of creating a knowledge-based economy at all levels of the education life-cycle. It will explore recommendations for Public-Private Partnerships that could enhance the learning ecosystem of GCC countries for their citizens. The workshop will also contribute to the literature on LOtC in the GCC, allowing for a repository of case studies such as desired practices for institutions and organisations, and encouraging NPOs, civilsociety groups and professional organisations to play a part in developing more targeted community-based programs for the youth. The workshop will analyze existing initiatives and efforts, address gaps, and examine opportunities and challenges facing LOtC in the following educational and professional stages:

  • K-12
  • Higher Education
  • Not-for-profit, Civic and Community-led domain
  • Vocational Education
  • Professional and Executive Education and Training

 

Anticipated Papers

Against the background presented above, this workshop would welcome papers that address the following questions:

  • What is the role of the GCC governments in facilitating access to learning centres such aslibraries and museums, and how can they develop existing centres to be more effectivedestinations for LOtC?
  • How are private schools (K-12) competing with each other in the provision of the mostcompetitive opportunities for LOtC and what opportunities existin increased partnerships betweeninstitutions?
  • How are social, personal and cognitive development enhanced through opportunities in LOtC inthe GCC context (socio-economic and other factors)? What trends have been measured orobserved?
  • What is the role of ICT in LOtC and life-long learning? How is ICT impacting LOtC among theyouth in the GCC?
  • What opportunities and challenges exist in introducing vocational education as LOtC throughPublic-Private Partnerships?
  • How do/can ‘industry’ partnerships impact STEM education in the GCC? What opportunitiesexist? How can governments in the GCC facilitate and encourage such collaboration?
  • How does/can tertiary education more effectively bridge the gap between the classroom andlabour market through opportunities in LOtC? What lessons can be learnt from existing initiativesat colleges and universities through partnerships between Academic and Student Affairs? Whatopportunities are untapped?
  • What is the impact and effectiveness of commercial initiatives focusing on LOtC? How canaccess be improved?
  • What roles do community-based learning and LOtC play in the identity-building and skillsdevelopment of youth in the GCC?
  • How has community-based education developed across the GCC countries and what outcomeshave been observed/achieved?
  • What are the factors contributing to the measurable success or failure of some private trainingprograms in the GCC? What lessons can be learned from them?
  • What emphasis is being placed on community initiatives (CSR) by private sector organisationsand to what end? What lessons can be learned or shared?

 

Workshop Directors Profiles

Dr. Asma Siddiki is an education management consultant and has been involved in the education and higher education sectors through working in the Middle East and Europe for the past 20 years. She is also the Chief Executive of Alpha1Education, LLC (which organises the summer program HeritageSummers at the Universities of Oxford and Cambridge for secondary school students, and other project and community-based learning programs).Dr. Siddiki most notably held leadership roles at universities in their early stages of development in the GCC focusing extensively on student services and co-curricular learning, institutional effectiveness, organisational development, and global institutional partnerships. More recently, she served as Director for the Global Higher Education practice of Huron Consulting Group in its Dubai office. She has also been involved in cross-cultural dialogue and relations between the West and Middle East, both officially and in a personal capacity. She is on the Committee of the Saudi-British Society. Dr. Siddiki received her doctoral degree from the University of Oxford’s Department of Experimental Psychology in Cognitive Development (2002). Earlier, she gained a Master of Studies from the Centre for Linguistics and Comparative Philology, University of Oxford (1998). Her alma mater is the King Abdul Aziz University in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia (B.A., 1995). Dr. Siddiki is a Saudi Arabian citizen and is based in Jeddah and Dubai.

Dr. Rania Ibrahim is the Dean for Student Affairs atEffat University, overseeing student enrollment; scholarships and financial aid; student life;and centers of independent learning and communication and rhetoric, career development alumnae services; and counseling. Dr. Ibrahim holds a Ph.D. in linguistics; MATEFL in EFL testing; Diploma in Applied Linguistics; B.A. in English Language and Literature. She received her graduate degrees from Reading University, UK and Alexandria University, Egypt. She has worked at Effat University since 2001 as faculty; Director of Effat Preparatory Program and Testing Center; Director of Enrollment; Student Affairs Vice Dean; and Dean for Student Affairs. In Egypt, she has been working in Alexandria University since 1991 teaching English for Specific Purposes courses for graduate and undergraduate students, and teacher-training courses for secondary and tertiary level teachers. She is currently on leave from her position in Egypt. Her research interests are in the areas of assessment, leadership, and student development.

Selected Readings

AlMunajjed, M. andK. Sabbagh.Youth in GCC Countries Meeting the Challenge.Booz & Company, Inc. Ideation Center Insight Paper, 2011,http://www.booz.com/media/file/BoozCo-GCC-Youth-Challenge.pdf (accessed September 22, 2013)

Barber, M., M. Mourshed, and F. Whelan.“Improving Education in the Gulf.”The MckinseyQuarterly, Special Edition: Reappraising the Gulf States 2007, 39-47.

Braund, M., and M.J.Reiss.(eds) .Learning Science Outside the Classroom(London: RoutledgeFalmer, 2004). Council for Learning Outside the Classroom http://www.lotc.org.uk/why/creativity-culture-and-the-arts/ (accessed September 28, 2013)

Farah, S. “Education Quality and Competitiveness in the UAE.” Sheikh Saud binSaqr Al Qasimi Foundation for Policy Research Working Paper No. 2, March 2012.

Gatto, J., H.Y. Hanson, D. Sayers, andN. Hanson.Educating Your Child in Modern Times.Kinza Academy, 2010.

Gonzalez, G., L.A. Karoly, L. Constant, H. Salem, and C.A. Goldman.“Facing Human Capital Challenges of the 21st Century: Education and Labor Market Initiatives in Lebanon,Oman, Qatar, and the United Arab Emirates.”Rand Monographs (MG-786), 2008.

Hanushek, E. A. “Why Education Quality Matters.”Finance and Development, 42, no. 2 (2005), International Monetary Fund.

Ibrahim, R and A. Sarirete.“A Constructivist Approach to Student Development: Effat University Case Study.”International Journal of Technology Enhanced Learning 3, no. 3, May 2011, 297-307(11).

International Baccalaureate Diploma.http://www.ibo.org/diploma/. (Accessed September 28, 2013).

Jamjoom, Mounira.Missing Link in GCC's Education Reform Strategy.

http://www.ameinfo.com/missing-link-gccs-education-reform-strategy-353666 (Accessed September 30, 2013.

Jawhar, S. Book Fair without Distractions Highlights Need for Libraries. Arab News, March 14, 2013.

Karoly, L.A. The Role of Education in Preparing Graduates for the Labor Market in the GCC Countries.Rand Working Paper Series (WR-742), 2010.

Kuh, G. (In Their Own Words: What Students Learn Outside the Classroom.American Educational Research Journal30 (June 20, 1993): 277-304.

Malone, K. (2008) Every Experience Matters: An Evidence based Research Reporton the Role of Learning outside the Classroom for Children’s Whole Development from Birth toEighteen Years.

Report commissioned by Farming and Countryside Education for UK Department Children, School and Families, Wollongong, Australia.

Sahlberg, P. “Education Policies for Raising Student Learning: the Finnish Approach.”

Journal of Education Policy 22, no. 2 (2007): 147-171.

Saleh-Isfahani, D., N. BlehajHassine, andR. Assad.Equality of Opportunity in Education in the Middle East and North Africa.Working paper.Cairo Economic Research Forum, 2011.

United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), Arab Human Development Report: Building a

Knowledge Society. New York: United Nations Development Programme, Regional Bureau for Arab States, 2003.

Wagner, T. The Global Achievement Gap: Why Even Our Best Schools Don'tTeach the New Survival Skills Our Children Need - and What We Can Do About it(Basic Books, 2009).

WITH THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF