GRM 2010 GRM 2011

WORKSHOP DETAILS

Title: The India-Gulf Strategic Partnership in a Pan-Asian Cooperative Paradigm

Workshop Directors:

Prof. Abu Backer Bagader
Professor of Sociology King Abdul Aziz University
Email: bagader@gmail.com
        
Amb. Ranjit Gupta (Retd.)
Former Member National Security Advisory Board
Email: ranjit.100@gmail.com
        

Workshop Description and Rationale

India’s links with the GCC at presentare made up of energy, trade and community-related ties. The GCC countries provide about 50 per cent of India’s oil imports with Saudi Arabia being the largest single supplier; if Iran and Iraq are taken in account, India’s supplies from the Gulf are around 80 per cent. Again, Qatar is the principal supplier of imported gas to India. In regard to economic ties, the GCC isIndia’s number one trade partner in terms of economic groupings, while the UAE is India’s number one trade partner on country-wise basis and as the leading destination of Indian exports. The Indian community in the six countries of the GCC numbers about six million, and is the preferred community in every GCC country. This community remits to India about $32-35 billion annually. 

Over the last few years,India’s ties with the Gulf countries have been going through major changes. Between 2005 and 2007, all the GCC countries indicated a deep interest in enhancing political and economic ties with India as manifested by the visits to India of the Heads of State/ Heads of Government of all the GCC countries, and regular visits by Indian leaders and Ministers to the region. This India-GCC interaction climaxed in February 2010 in the signing of the Riyadh Declaration by the Indian Prime Minister, Dr. Manmohan Singh, and the Saudi monarch, King Abdullah bin Abdul Aziz Al-Saud, which envisaged the realization of “a new era of strategic partnership.”

However, India also has substantial ties with Iran: Iran is the second largest supplier of oil to India and is therefore important for its energy security interests. Again, Iran is central to the safeguarding of India’s interests in Afghanistan. It is also one of the gateways for movement of Indian goods to Central Asia, Russia and Europe along the North-South corridor from the Iranian port of Bandar Abbas to the Caspian Sea region, and then north to Russia and Europe.

As India’s ties with the Gulf region evolve to a strategic level, several enduring and new issues need to be addressed:

  • Energy
  • Economic interests
  • Nuclear issues
  • Maritime issues
  • Defense and security ties
  • Regional aspirations consequent on the “Arab Spring”
  • Islam in its radical and moderate manifestations
  • Indian community’s interests

 

Pan-Asian Cooperation

Given India’s substantial and abiding interests in the Gulf, India cannot maintain a business-as-usual scenario nor do its political traditions and long-term interests allow it to become a junior partner in a US-led Western alliance. Again, given the ongoing Saudi-Iranian competitiveness, the option of pursuing significantly enhanced security engagements with the GCC and/or Iran entirely by itself is probably not a practical proposition. The only viable long-term policy approach possible for India is pursuing a broader “cooperative security approach” in tandem with other Asian role-players committed to Gulf security that would blunt the competitive age of Saudi-Iranian relations and incrementally build a framework that would embrace the principal countries of Asia, all of which have a crucial stake in Gulf security. An important step in this direction would be for India to encourage the setting up ofdialogue partnership arrangementson the lines of the ASEAN Regional Forum (ARF) with principal regional and extra-regional interlocutors. This policy approach would have to take into account the interests of other regional and external players and their ties with each other, which may be summarized as follows:

Regional Role Players: Saudi-Iran relationsare likely to constitute the single most important element of the regional scenario, impacting on important political and economic developments in the region as also on the ties that external players, including India, seek to have with different countries of the Gulf. The robust Saudi posture in this contention also suggests that the Kingdom, while maintaining close security-based and economic links with the United States, might not, in future, depend exclusively on it for its security, thus opening up opportunities for other role players to participate in the regional security scenarios.

The principal neighboring countrieswhose roles/interests influence Gulf affairs are Turkey, Israel, Iraq and Pakistan. Insofar as Israel is concerned, there is little doubt that one of the responses of the regional leaderships to the Arab Spring would be an enhanced interest in the Palestine question, which would have implications for Israel’s domestic politics and its ties with the other countries in the region, particularly Egypt and Turkey, and the US. At the same time, Israel would continue to see Iran as its strategic rival, and could even take up the military option if it were convinced that Iran’s emergence as a nuclear power was imminent. This would have complex implications for the region itself as also for the countries seeking an enhanced profile in the region.

Though Iraq continues to display considerable political uncertainty, given its historic importance in the region and its substantial energy potential, it is likely to emerge as an influential regional player. Again, Turkey has a major potential influence in the region both as a model for the nascent polities emerging in the aftermath of the “Arab Spring” and as a potentially moderating factor, with close ties with the West (USA and NATO) and with Syria, Iran and Israel. The political situation in Afghanistanwill also impact on the region in terms of concerns pertaining to the danger of radical Islam; Pakistan’s search for “strategic depth” in Afghanistan; increasing radicalization of state and non-state elements in Pakistan, and Pakistan’s ties with the GCC and Iran.

External Role Players: The most influential external player in the Gulf has been the United States. After its rather limited successes in Iraq and Afghanistan and the consequent economic pressures upon it, the US appears to be a much-diminished power in the region. However, the US’s interests in the region pertaining to energy flows and Israel’s security remain undiminished, even as it is still the only global player which remains committed to and can guarantee the security of the GCC countries. Hence, inevitably, the GCC countries will continue to maintain the closest possible security links with the US, based on the continued presence of the US Navy in Gulf waters and its longterm presence in Iraq and Afghanistan.

China, has the potential of playing an increasingly influential role and, like India, has enormous stakes in the security and wellbeing of the Gulf, while having substantial economic ties both with Iran and the GCC countries.  It also continues to maintain an all-weather friendship with Pakistan. However, China has not so far projected a strategic role in the Gulf,though, given the importance of the region to its interests, this could change.

 

Thematic or Country Studies Papers

Based on the analyses provided above and within the framework of India-Gulf strategic partnership, participants in the workshop should in their papers look at the interests of the Gulf countries as also the interests of other major Asian countries and the external role players in the region, and their ties with each other, and explore areas of convergence and divergence among them, with the central focus being the pursuit of a Pan-Asian Cooperative Security Partnership.  The topics would include:

I           Gulf Politics

1.      The impact of the “Arab Spring” and prospects for internal reform.

2.      The Arab Spring versus Islam: the role of “Islam” in defining aspirations of the people.

3.      The impact of the “Arab Spring” on the international relations of the region.

4.      The future of the GCC as the guardian of its members’ political, security, defense and economic interests.

5.      Relations of GCC’s members with Iran, particularly prospects for Saudi-Iranian relations.

II         External Relations / Security Issues

1.      India’s Interests and Role in the Gulf.

2.      The Interests and Role of Turkey in the Gulf.

3.      The Interests and Role of Pakistan in the Gulf.

4.      Egypt’s Relations with Saudi Arabia and Iran.

5.      GCC-US Relations.

6.      GCC-EU Relations.

7.      Iran-US Relations.

8.      China and India in the Gulf: Competition or Cooperation?

9.      India-Iran Relations.

10.  Realizing an Asian Cooperative Security Alliance: the Indian Role.

11.  Setting up a dialogue partnership with the GCC: a possible approach on the ARF model.

12.  Security challenges in the Gulf and the Indian Ocean: the Case for an Asian Cooperative Security Alliance.

13.  The Continuing Threat from Radical Islam: the challenge to South Asia, the Gulf and WANA from post-Osama Al Qaeda.

14.  The Pak-Taliban nexus and Security Concerns for India and the Gulf.

III        Energy/Economic Interests

1.      Asia’s energy security interests in the Gulf: Prospects for Pan-Asian Cooperation.

2.      Giving substance to Gulf’s “Look-East” policies: expansion of two-way trade, investments and joint ventures.

IV        Human Resources and Cultural Ties

1.      The GCC’s “Localization” policies and the continuing need for expatriate human resources: reconciling the interests of sending and receiving countries.

2.      Expanding Asia-Gulf cultural and people-to-people engagements.

3.      Asian countries as social, economic and political development models for the GCC.

 

Anticipated Participants

We are seeking participants from a wide range of backgrounds: Gulf researchers with interests in this field, Indian researchers with a record of Gulf involvement, other scholars with expertise in particular dimensions of the relationship. The involvement of young scholars (including Ph.D. students who are engaged in this field) would be particularly welcome.

 

Workshop Director Profiles

Ranjit Gupta is a retired Indian Foreign Service officer. During his 39-year career with the Ministry of External Affairs, he served successively in Cairo, New York, Gangtok, Jeddah (Deputy Chief of Mission), Frankfurt and Kathmandu. Later, he was successively India’s Ambassador to Yemen (North), Venezuela, Oman, Thailand and Spain and finally was Head of the non-official Office in Taiwan. One of his postings at Headquarters was as Head of the West Asia and North Africa Division in the Ministry of External Affairs dealing with Arab countries. Currently, he is a Distinguished Fellow of the Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies; and, a visiting Fellow at the Institute of Chinese Studies. Until recently, he was a Member of India’s National Security Advisory Board. He is leading the Indian team in a joint research project on India-GCC Relations sponsored by India's Ministry of External Affairs with the Gulf Research Center; he has very recently been granted a two-year research project on India-GCC Relations by the Indian Council of World Affairs. He has been delivering lectures at think tanks and other academic institutions in India and abroad and participating in conferences, seminars and workshops primarily relating to India's relations with the Gulf region, Southeast Asia and East Asia, as well as countries and issues of relevance to these regions.

Abu Backer Bagader is professor of social sciences at King Abdul Aziz University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. He recently completed his term as Deputy Minister for International Cultural Relations in the Ministry for Culture and Information. He is an active member of Arab Council for Social Sciences and many other similar social organizations. He has authored more than 10 books on subjects related to the Middle East, including history, social science, literature, human rights, Arab women’s social issues, environmental concerns, Muslim minorities and poverty in the Gulf Cooperation Council countries. Prof. Bagader is also well versed with Indian history, literature and culture.

WITH THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF